Is active surveillance right for you? The answer to this question varies, depending on a bunch of factors: your particular form of prostate cancer, your age and general health, and also on the criteria used to select men for active surveillance programs from hospital to hospital.
First, what is active surveillance? The key word here is “active.” This is not what doctors years ago used to call “watchful waiting,” where a guy with prostate cancer didn’t have the cancer removed or treated with radiation; he just lived his life until he developed symptoms, and then those symptoms were treated. The cancer itself was not gone after aggressively, and many of those men died of cancer – but the hope was that they were old enough to die of something else first.
Active surveillance is completely different.
Men who are eligible for active surveillance have cancer that shows all signs of being the “good” kind: slow-growing, low-volume (meaning, there’s not very much of it in all the tissue samples from your prostate biopsy), not aggressive.
Active Surveillance Questions
Get an Email with Questions for your doctor
Can men live with slow-growing, low-volume prostate cancer? Absolutely. The proof of this is found every day, in many thousands of autopsies done around the world, of men in their eighties and older who died of something else – a heart attack, for instance. Then, in the autopsy, the pathologist looks at the man’s prostate and sees cancer in there. This cancer is what doctors call “indolent.” It’s low-risk. Slow-growing, low-volume. It sits there. It doesn’t cause any harm, and clearly never needed to be treated, because the guy never knew he had it and died of something else. When urologist Christopher Barbieri, M.D., Ph.D., on the faculty at Weill Cornell Medicine at New York Presbyterian, talks to his patients who are candidates for active surveillance, he tells them, “You’re more likely to get hit by a bus when you’re 100 years old than for this cancer to kill you.”
Let us digress for a moment and think of prostate cancer in the form of an animal. The most aggressive cancer is like a bird; it grows quickly, and is very likely to fly away from the prostate to other places in the body, making it more difficult to kill. The least aggressive cancer moves like – well, something slow, a turtle, or a sloth. And then there are men with the cancers in between – let’s think of them as rabbits — cancers that do need to be treated with surgery or radiation.
Indolent prostate cancer is the pet rock of cancers; it doesn’t do much, but the upside of that is that it doesn’t need to be treated, either.
Important point: Cancer may not stay indolent. Or, from the initial biopsy and test results it might appear to be low-risk and or low-volume, but actually more cancer is there and the biopsy needle just missed it. So, men who choose active surveillance may not stay on it forever if their cancer undergoes “grade reclassification” – if, that is, you have another biopsy and it suggests that more cancer is present, or that it may not be so slothlike in personality. So if you choose active surveillance, know that at some point, you may need to have surgery or radiation.
Choosing active surveillance – remember the keyword is “active” – means that you will need to keep getting your cancer checked out. You will need to get follow-up PSA tests, exams, and biopsies, maybe once a year, for many years. If you are a young man, say age 50, and you could reasonably expect to live another 40 years, this could mean that you get your prostate stuck with needles many, many more times in your life. (Not until you’re 90, but at least another 15 years or so.) Biopsies have their own risks. (See separate article – hyperlink here.) You may not want to subject yourself to this.
You will also have to live your life knowing you have cancer. Can you handle this? Some men can’t. Thinking about the cancer in there makes them anxious. To them, it’s like a time bomb – when actually, it may not be a time bomb at all, but more of a clock just happily ticking away, not causing harm – and they end up having surgery or radiation just for the peace of mind.
On the other hand, if you can live with it — trusting that the follow-up monitoring will detect any change if it happens and that if you need to get treatment, you won’t miss that window of treatment when the cancer is still confined to the prostate, and you will have plenty of time to make that decision — then active surveillance may be a good option for you.
Terms to know from this article:
Active surveillance is an option offered to patients with very low-risk prostate cancer (low grade, low stage, localized disease). Patients are monitored carefully over time for signs of disease progression. A PSA blood test and digital rectal exam (DRE) and prostate biopsy are performed at physician-specified intervals. Signs of disease progression will trigger immediate active treatment.
The removal of cells or tissues for examination under a microscope. When only a sample of tissue is removed, the procedure is called an incisional biopsy or core biopsy. When an entire lump or suspicious area is removed, the procedure is called an excisional biopsy. When a sample of tissue or fluid is removed with a needle, the procedure is called a needle biopsy or fine-needle aspiration.
A doctor who identifies diseases by studying cells and tissues under a microscope.
A doctor who has special training in diagnosing and treating diseases of the urinary organs in females and the urinary and reproductive organs in males.
The grade of a tumor depends on how abnormal the cancer cells look under a microscope and how quickly the tumor is likely to grow and spread. Grading systems are different for each type of cancer.
prostate-specific antigen (PSA): A substance produced by the prostate that may be found in an increased amount in the blood of men who have prostate cancer, benign prostatic hyperplasia, or infection or inflammation of the prostate.